Industry Research Reports and Market Analysis at MindBranch.com
  

Printer OEMs Defend Supplies Investment with Legal Clout

Product Type: Market Research Report
Published by: InfoTrends/CAP Ventures
Published: October 2007
Product Code: R290-367
Description
In the past year, many major printer manufacturers have been aggressively protecting their intellectual property, particularly when it comes to supplies. This protection has taken many different forms, ranging from an official letter to the filing a lawsuit in Court. There have also been several instances of printer OEMs (original equipment manufacturers) sending formal letters to remind aftermarket companies that their products could be infringing patents. HP took this route with several companies, including Cartridge World, OfficeMax, Walgreens, and InkCycle.

Regardless of the method, the point is the same. Printer manufacturers are making it clear that while they understand that there will be competition for supplies sales, companies offering aftermarket or compatible supplies cannot infringe any of their patents in selling those supplies. In the end, the printer manufacturers have largely been successful in their pursuits. Aftermarket companies that were found to be infringing patents have been ordered to pay settlements and/or stop selling the infringing product in a particular area. Some feel that this success on the part of the OEMs is largely due to the deep pockets that these companies have to fight legal battles. In contrast, most aftermarket companies are much smaller and have fewer resources.
Table of Contents
Introduction

Legal Cases

Canon

Canon vs. ETIRA

Canon vs. GCC

Canon vs. Recycle Assist

Epson (Seiko Epson)

Seiko Epson vs. CybaHouse Limited

Epson vs. 24 Companies: General Exclusion

Epson vs. Armour Group

Seiko Epson vs. Four Online Retailers

Seiko Epson vs. U-Bar International Co., Ltd.

Seiko Epson vs. Medea

Seiko Epson vs. Ecorica, Inc.

Epson vs. E-Babylon Corp., Linkyo Corp., Cartridges Are Us, and Printpal

Hewlett-Packard Company

Hewlett-Packard vs. InkTec

HP vs. Ninestar

HP vs. Pelikan

Static Control

Static Control vs. Future Graphics, LLC

Static Control vs. Lexmark… and Others

Xerox

Conclusion

Ordering and More Information
Price and Delivery Options



MindBranch has been the leading provider of industry and investment research from more than 550 independent research firms since 1992. With over 90,000 market research reports, MindBranch is your trusted source of competitive business intelligence.